Home › Ohio › Elyria › New To You Resale Shop

New To You Resale Shop

4.6 ★★★★★ 61 Google reviews · Plus size clothing in Elyria, Ohio

New To You Resale Shop, plus size clothing store in Elyria, OH — photo 2

New To You Resale Shop, plus size clothing store in Elyria, OH — photo 3

New To You Resale Shop, plus size clothing store in Elyria, OH — photo 4

Plus-size-friendly retail store for pre-owned clothing and housewares, plus rentals of vintage costumes.

Plan your visit

Today see hours ·
Phone (440) 322-0755

Hours

Monday	Closed
Tuesday	10 AM–6 PM
Wednesday	10 AM–6 PM
Thursday	10 AM–6 PM
Friday	10 AM–6 PM
Saturday	10 AM–5 PM
Sunday	Closed

Hours can shift for holidays, trunk shows, and private appointments — worth a quick check before a special trip.

What's on the racks

Clothing categories at New To You Resale Shop, confirmed in shoppers' own reviews and the store's own info — not guessed from the sign out front.

 👰 Plus Size Bridal  
All stores with plus size bridal →
 ♻️ Plus Size Consignment & Resale  
All stores with plus size consignment & resale →
 💍 Accessories & Jewelry 2 mentions 
“She has really nice quality clothes at a good price and she also has a nice selection of jewelry”
All stores with accessories & jewelry →
 👠 Wide-Width Shoes 2 mentions 
“An amazing selection of clothing, shoes, and household items.”
All stores with wide-width shoes →

What shoppers say again and again

The things reviewers bring up again and again across 61 Google reviews — with their own words as proof.

🧼 spotless & clean 3 mentions

“Very Clean comfy surroundings and the merchandise is clean well looked over by that I mean I haven't seen any stains on clothes, holes etc.”

💵 good value 4 mentions

“She has really nice quality clothes at a good price and she also has a nice selection of jewelry”

From the reviews

One of my favorites! Owner and staff are very polite and happy to help you. Very Clean comfy surroundings and the merchandise is clean well looked over by that I mean I haven't seen any stains on clothes, holes etc.

★★★★★ — Stacey, May 2023

Super cute place! Friendly staff. Wonderful prices. Clothes for ALL adult sizes, including plus size! Changing room is open! Make sure you know what color tags have discounts while you're there.

★★★★★ — Sami, Jul 2024

I found the GREATEST pair of BABY PHAT jeans there in 2017... i lost them somehow last year (2023) and am so upset.... heading back there today!!

★★★★★ — Sandee, Dec 2024

An amazing selection of clothing, shoes, and household items. The store was clean, staff friendly , and the pricing was okay.

★★★★★ — Genia, Mar 2025

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 61 reviews →

Where to find New To You Resale Shop

625 Broad St, Elyria, OH44035

Get directions

Plus size stores near New To You Resale Shop

Discount Fashion Warehouse Elyria

4.2 ★★★★☆ 602 reviews

285 Midway Blvd, Elyria, OH

Bridal & formal finds around $10 great fitting roomsgood value

Vast, size-sorted retailer offering affordable clothing, footwear and accessories, including brand names and plus-sized attire.

2.2 miles away

The Clothing Loft Boutique

4.8 ★★★★★ 81 reviews

1917 Cooper Foster Park Rd, Amherst, OH

Boutique friendly staffgood value

Boutique offering trendy women's apparel in a variety of sizes, plus shoes and bags.

5.7 miles away

Rainbow Shops

4.3 ★★★★☆ 121 reviews

1069 Meister Rd, Lorain, OH

Sizes 14–20

Bridal & formal Extended sizes 4X+ good value

Apparel chain offering fashionable clothing for women, men & kids, as well as shoes & accessories.

6.2 miles away

All plus size stores in Elyria, OH →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and shopper reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this store? Claim your listing — it's free.