Home › Pennsylvania › Chambersburg › Why Buy New Consignment Shop

Why Buy New Consignment Shop

3.9 ★★★★☆ 166 Google reviews · Plus size clothing in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania

Furnishings, apparel, pre-owned items, plus-sized clothing and footwear provider that also sells walkers and electronics.

Plan your visit

Today see hours ·
Phone (717) 504-8089

Hours

Monday	10 AM–5 PM
Tuesday	10 AM–5 PM
Wednesday	10 AM–5 PM
Thursday	10 AM–5 PM
Friday	10 AM–5 PM
Saturday	10 AM–5 PM
Sunday	Closed

Hours can shift for holidays, trunk shows, and private appointments — worth a quick check before a special trip.

What's on the racks

Clothing categories at Why Buy New Consignment Shop, confirmed in shoppers' own reviews and the store's own info — not guessed from the sign out front.

♻️ Plus Size Consignment & Resale 6 mentions

“I love antique shops, consignments, and just exploring- Chambersburg is gorgeous!”

All stores with plus size consignment & resale →

What shoppers say again and again

The things reviewers bring up again and again across 166 Google reviews — with their own words as proof.

💵 good value 5 mentions

“While the prices were a bit high on some things, I did find a couple of good deals.”

✨ quality pieces 3 mentions

“I did purchase some items, which were beautiful, great quality and priced very reasonably.”

From the reviews

I drove up to Chambersburg from northern VA to spend time with family. I love antique shops, consignments, and just exploring- Chambersburg is gorgeous! I had limited time to spend exploring before meeting with family.

★★★★★ — Afroze, Aug 2020

Love this store and the helpful friendly folks that work there are incredibly helpful but no pressure. I moved here from North Carolina my granddaughter said I'd love this shop, and she is so right.

★★★★★ — Joan, Jun 2021

Absolutely love this store they have everything you possibly could need for low prices, the owners are very sweet and have helped me so much. They have a dress store in the back as well perfect for any proms, dances, or weddings. Definitely will return.

★★★★★ — Cassidi, Oct 2025

Great consignment store, huge selection of everything at reasonable prices. VERY polite staff, always willing to help find whatever you are looking for.

★★★★★ — Darrell, Mar 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 166 reviews →

Where to find Why Buy New Consignment Shop

925 Lincoln Way W, Chambersburg, PA17202

Get directions

Plus size stores near Why Buy New Consignment Shop

Maurices

4.1 ★★★★☆ 56 reviews

1320 Lincoln Way E, Chambersburg, PA

friendly staffgood value

Women's clothing chain for current fashions in a range of sizes, plus footwear & accessories.

3.0 miles away

Cato Fashions

4.2 ★★★★☆ 61 reviews

101 Conestoga Dr, Shippensburg, PA

Bridal & formal good value

Chain with stylish apparel for women ranging from junior to plus sizes, along with accessories.

13.2 miles away

K&B Bridals and Tux

4.9 ★★★★★ 757 reviews

710 Dual Hwy, Hagerstown, MD

Bridal & formal Boutique body-positive experiencepersonal styling helpgreat dress selection

Formal-wear, wedding and prom outfitters for brides, with a wide selection of gowns, tuxedos and accessories.

20.8 miles away

All plus size stores in Chambersburg, PA →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and shopper reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this store? Claim your listing — it's free.