The best plus size stores in Indiana
Ranked by the shoppers who actually try things on — Google rating weighted by review volume, across 25,042 reviews of Indiana stores. Minimum 25 reviews to qualify, true plus size clothing stores only, one location per chain, and nobody pays for a spot. Updated 2026.
#1 DXL Big + Tall
4.8 ★★★★★ 398 reviews · Merrillville, IN
Retail chain for men's casualwear, brand-name suits & shoes in a wide selection of larger sizes.
“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️– Thank You, Men’s Wearhouse… for Sending Me to DXL! Shoutout to Connie and Scott at DXL Merrillville—you’ve got a customer for life. After being completely ignored by fo…” — Ronald
#2 World Wide Missions Consignment Store
4.4 ★★★★☆ 582 reviews · Evansville, IN
Spacious, family-friendly store with clothing, toys and books, plus occasional half-price sales.
“The largest selection of items I have ever seen in my entire life. The store goes on forever. If you can think of it, you can probably find one here. Racks full of clothes for all …” — Sarah
#3 Big & Tall Outlet
4.5 ★★★★★ 452 reviews · Elkhart, IN
Store selling brand-name, sale-priced apparel, shoes & accessories in extra-long & wide sizes.
“Amazing that we have a store like this local here! They have a HUGE basement full of discounted clothes (but be sure to try them on bc you can't return discounted items). The top f…” — 7
#4 Catherine's Bridal Boutique
4.7 ★★★★★ 303 reviews · Valparaiso, IN
Full-service standby for wedding gowns & dresses for bridal parties, proms & other big occasions.
“I took my bridesmaids and mom to Catherine’s bridal trunk show in the fall. Be organized and make sure your group knows your style. We were able to find the dress of my dreams at a…” — Rachel
#5 Torrid
4.5 ★★★★★ 290 reviews · Greenwood, IN
Women's clothing chain known for its trendy plus-size cocktail dresses, jeans, lingerie & footwear.
“As always, the staff are helpful, friendly and welcoming. I love skulls and these 2 knew where every single one in the store was located!! I absolutely love the style and selection…” — A
#6 Citi Trends
4.1 ★★★★☆ 285 reviews · Merrillville, IN
Retail chain selling brand-name streetwear at a discount, plus accessories, shoes & decor items.
“It was my birthday weekend and needed a replacement outfit to wear. I found an outfit to wear for my birthday at a reasonable cost. The young lady with the short blond hair has exc…” — La
#7 Clothes Mentor Fishers, IN
4.1 ★★★★☆ 236 reviews · Fishers, IN
Resale clothing chain stocking pre-owned brand-name apparel, shoes & accessories for women.
“My favorite store!!! You can not beat the awesome clothes at amazing prices! Everyone that works here is very friendly and helpful. I love shopping the clearance rack. I love the w…” — Kim
#8 Lane Bryant
4.4 ★★★★☆ 159 reviews · Mishawaka, IN
Women's clothing chain with fashionable plus-size clothing, lingerie, shoes & accessories.
“Young lady at checkout was kind, I was greeted as I shopped around, store was clean and merchandise easy to find/actually sized correctly. 5 stars for the store operations and the …” — Jennifer
#9 Maurices
4.5 ★★★★★ 137 reviews · Fort Wayne, IN
Women's clothing chain for current fashions in a range of sizes, plus footwear & accessories.
“I love Maurices. I can always find something cute that doesn't make me look like an old lady and also doesn't make me look like a teenager. They have excellent prices on their clea…” — Sara
#10 Cato Fashions
4.6 ★★★★★ 115 reviews · La Porte, IN
Chain with stylish apparel for women ranging from junior to plus sizes, along with accessories.
“I love this store. It's just a shame they don't get all the styles that the website has. It never fails I see something I love on line & 95% of the time our store never gets it.” — Renee