The best plus size stores in New York
Ranked by the shoppers who actually try things on — Google rating weighted by review volume, across 58,561 reviews of New York stores. Minimum 25 reviews to qualify, true plus size clothing stores only, one location per chain, and nobody pays for a spot. Updated 2026.
#1 The Rack Shack (Brooklyn)
5 ★★★★★ 632 reviews · Brooklyn, NY
Compact, chic store focusing on ladies' lingerie in a wide range of sizes.
“Amazing experience. The employees are so kind. They found my bra size quickly and I left with a bunch of awesome bras and matching panties. They even have swimwear and bodysuits by…” — Darks
#2 DXL Big + Tall
4.7 ★★★★★ 359 reviews · Rochester, NY
Retail chain for men's casualwear, brand-name suits & shoes in a wide selection of larger sizes.
“The person who helped me.and my son, who I believe is the store manager, pickout close for.his Junior Prom was probably the most helpful person I've delt with in a sales position. …” — Thaddeus
#3 Lane Bryant
4.4 ★★★★☆ 435 reviews · Brooklyn, NY
Women's clothing chain with fashionable plus-size clothing, lingerie, shoes & accessories.
“I just got to say that I love lady Bryant, as a father with three girls and of course a wife, and family. They take American seriously, when it comes to clothing, you know of cours…” — Eddie
#4 Rainbow Shops
4.1 ★★★★☆ 559 reviews · Brooklyn, NY
Apparel chain offering fashionable clothing for women, men & kids, as well as shoes & accessories.
“Lovely, polite staff. They were perfectly willing to remove clothing from their window displays and/or mannequins to accommodate the purchase of items for my small-framed teenager.…” — Gs
#5 Clothes Mentor West Seneca, NY
4.5 ★★★★★ 309 reviews · West Seneca, NY
Resale clothing chain stocking pre-owned brand-name apparel, shoes & accessories for women.
“My beautiful 83 year old mom is bravely fighting Stage 4 cancer. She needed the perfect look for her grandson’s wedding this past weekend that helped her stay safe outdoors in the …” — Bethann
#6 Park Avenue Coat Company
4.3 ★★★★☆ 393 reviews · Lackawanna, NY
Clothing store stocking a large selection of winter coats and jackets from well-known brands.
“Great deals on premium quality name brand clothing and winter attire. The store has a clean, well kept, industrial aesthetic and the employees are always very polite and helpful.” — Side
#7 Plus BKLYN
4.8 ★★★★★ 202 reviews · Brooklyn, NY
Store offering new and used clothing and accessories in sizes for plus-size women.
“It took me a while to post a review of this wonderful rare find ! I accidentally run into this plus size store & I just loved it. Ended up buying multiple items ! I just wish it wa…” — Ratna
#8 Peter Harris Clothes
4.5 ★★★★★ 271 reviews · East Greenbush, NY
Clothing store selling apparel for women, men, and kids at discounted prices.
“When I’m in East Greenbush for the gym, I stop and pick out my outlets, then return later in week to bring back anything I don’t want. They are extremely friendly and kind. I’ve al…” — Kim
#9 Torrid
4.5 ★★★★★ 258 reviews · Bronx, NY
Women's clothing chain known for its trendy plus-size cocktail dresses, jeans, lingerie & footwear.
“Shopping in torrid clothing store for almost five years, so sad to see this store going out of business this covid-19 had messed up a lot of people . Customer service are excellent…” — Kenya
#10 Citi Trends
4 ★★★★☆ 455 reviews · Cheektowaga, NY
Retail chain selling brand-name streetwear at a discount, plus accessories, shoes & decor items.
“It wasn't Burlington but it's not the corner store either. Very clean, where i shopped, and the staff was friendly. Great placed to grab a quick outfit from the hat to shoes. Sole …” — Capitaldcp