HomeTypesPlus Size Consignment & Resale › New York

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in New York

New York has 12 stores with plus size consignment & resale in this directory, across 10 cities — Brooklyn, Buffalo, Middletown, New Hartford and 6 more. Stores are grouped by city below and ranked by local reputation (rating weighted by review count) — each listing shows the size-range evidence and shopper quotes behind the label.

Category labels come from each store's own website and shoppers' reviews; stock rotates, so call ahead for a specific piece or size.

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in Brooklyn, NY

Plus BKLYN

4.8 ★★★★★ 202 reviews

671 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY

Sizes 14–20

Big & tall Extended sizes 4X+ Boutique finds around $30 actually stocks extended sizesgreat fitting roomsfriendly staff

Store offering new and used clothing and accessories in sizes for plus-size women.

Rainbow Shops

4.2 ★★★★☆ 183 reviews

1220 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY

Sizes 14–20

Bridal & formal Extended sizes 4X+ good value

Apparel chain offering fashionable clothing for women, men & kids, as well as shoes & accessories.

Berriez

5 ★★★★★ 70 reviews

544 Park Ave #508, Brooklyn, NY

Sizes 18–20

Extended sizes 4X+ Boutique

Bright store showcasing a curated selection of vintage clothing and reworked garments for plus-size women, plus accessories.

All plus size stores in Brooklyn, NY →

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in Buffalo, NY

Citi Trends

4.1 ★★★★☆ 384 reviews

2101 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY

great fitting roomsgood value

Retail chain selling brand-name streetwear at a discount, plus accessories, shoes & decor items.

All plus size stores in Buffalo, NY →

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in Middletown, NY

Lovely Ladies

4 ★★★★☆ 72 reviews

280 NY-211 East, Middletown, NY

friendly staffgood valuequality pieces

Consignment store stocking mostly new merchandise, plus pre-owned handbags, jewelry and more, at low prices.

All plus size stores in Middletown, NY →

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in New Hartford, NY

Village Basement

4.8 ★★★★★ 91 reviews

70 Genesee St, New Hartford, NY

finds around $60 good value

Consignment shop offering apparel and home decor, including plus sizes, in a boutique setting.

All plus size stores in New Hartford, NY →

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in Oneonta, NY

Shakedown Street

4.4 ★★★★☆ 66 reviews

248 S Main St, Oneonta, NY

Extended sizes 4X+ spotless & cleanfriendly staff

Consignment shop featuring clothing and other items, plus food.

All plus size stores in Oneonta, NY →

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in St James, NY

Thic Chic Plus Size Boutique

4.7 ★★★★★ 9 reviews

367 Lake Ave, St James, NY

Sizes 12–22

Extended sizes 4X+ Boutique actually stocks extended sizesgood value

All plus size stores in St James, NY →

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in Syracuse, NY

Clothes Mentor Syracuse, NY

3.6 ★★★★☆ 173 reviews

3208 Erie Blvd E, Syracuse, NY

Shoppers mention sizes 18–22 fitting here

finds around $15 actually stocks extended sizesgreat fitting rooms

Resale clothing chain stocking pre-owned brand-name apparel, shoes & accessories for women.

All plus size stores in Syracuse, NY →

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in Vestal, NY

Talbots

3.8 ★★★★☆ 28 reviews

4777 Vestal Pkwy E, Vestal, NY

Big & tall actually stocks extended sizes

Women's apparel chain offering workwear, dresses, casual clothes & accessories in classic styles.

All plus size stores in Vestal, NY →

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in Warwick, NY

Savvy Chic Consignment Boutique

4.4 ★★★★☆ 19 reviews

26 Ronald Reagan Blvd, Warwick, NY

Boutique

All plus size stores in Warwick, NY →

Plus Size Consignment & Resale in West Seneca, NY

Clothes Mentor West Seneca, NY

4.5 ★★★★★ 309 reviews

1014 Union Rd, West Seneca, NY

spotless & cleanfriendly staffgood value

Resale clothing chain stocking pre-owned brand-name apparel, shoes & accessories for women.

All plus size stores in West Seneca, NY →

See all plus size stores in New York or all stores with plus size consignment & resale nationwide.